Understanding California's criminal threats statute—elements of the crime, potential defenses, and the serious consequences of conviction.
Criminal threats under Penal Code 422 is one of California's most commonly charged violent offenses—and one of the most misunderstood. Words alone, without any physical contact, can result in felony charges and years in prison. As a "strike" offense, a PC 422 conviction can haunt you for life.
California Penal Code 422 makes it illegal to threaten to commit a crime that would result in death or great bodily injury to another person, when the threat is made with the specific intent that it be taken as a threat, and when the threat causes the victim to be in sustained fear.
Making a serious threat to kill or seriously injure someone, intending them to take it seriously, and actually scaring them in a lasting way.
To convict you of criminal threats, the prosecution must prove ALL five elements beyond a reasonable doubt. If any element is missing, the charge fails.
The threat must be to commit a crime that would result in death or great bodily injury. Threats of minor harm don't qualify.
Can be spoken, written, texted, emailed, or communicated through electronic means. Gestures alone are not enough.
You meant for the recipient to understand your statement as a genuine threat, not as a joke or exaggeration.
The threat must be clear and definite—vague warnings or conditional statements may not qualify.
The fear must be reasonable and sustained (not fleeting or momentary)—the victim must have genuinely feared for their safety.
The "sustained fear" requirement is critical and often contested. The fear must be:
A reasonable person in the victim's situation would have felt fear. An unreasonable or irrational fear doesn't satisfy this element.
The fear must last more than a fleeting moment. Courts have held that even 15 minutes of fear can qualify as "sustained," but momentary fright does not.
You can be convicted of criminal threats even if you didn't actually intend to carry out the threat. What matters is that you intended the victim to take it as a threat—not whether you intended to follow through.
Criminal threats is a "wobbler" offense in California, meaning it can be charged as either a misdemeanor or a felony.
| Classification | Maximum Jail/Prison | Maximum Fine | Strike Offense? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Misdemeanor | Up to 1 year county jail | $1,000 | No |
| Felony | 16 months, 2, or 3 years state prison | $10,000 | YES - Strike Offense |
Vague statements like "you'll be sorry" or "I'm going to get you" may not meet the requirement that the threat be specific and unequivocal.
If you were joking, venting, or being hyperbolic and didn't intend for the statement to be taken as a genuine threat, this element isn't satisfied.
If the victim didn't actually fear for their safety—or their fear wasn't reasonable—the crime isn't complete.
Momentary or fleeting fear doesn't qualify. If the victim immediately dismissed the threat or wasn't afraid for any significant duration, this element fails.
A threat that depends on something else happening ("If you do X, then I'll...") may not be immediate enough to qualify.
Some threatening-sounding statements may be protected as hyperbole, political speech, or artistic expression. Context matters enormously.
In domestic disputes and custody battles, false accusations of criminal threats are unfortunately common.
Criminal threats charges are often filed alongside:
Facing criminal threat charges? The specific words and context matter enormously. Get an attorney who can analyze your case.
Get a Free Case Evaluation